Improving the Librarian Image (ALA 2008)

August 1, 2008

I decided to attend a session (which had people standing all the way out in the hall to listen–125 was the number I overheard on the way out) at ALA on Improving the Librarian Image because I am always interested in hearing about how the rest of the public perceives us and how to facilitate change. Donna Cardillo is a Registered Nurse and so that was also interesting.

A big take home for me was the use of credentials. I know it may be a bigger issue in nursing to show you have the full credentials to be a nurse but I can see a reason in libraries as well. Cardillo noted that, like in hospitals, patrons often do not know who is a librarian and who is a secretary or student assistant in libraries. She recommended having business cards made up with your name, title and credentials. The title also helps to further differentiate you; in this way the public can see that librarians are not all identical. The credentials can also help patrons, students, or faculty realize you have a Master’s degree, possibly adding more respect and buy-in from the communities we serve.

As an introduction she said, “Now some of you may be wondering why an RN is speaking at a library conference. What do nurses have to do with librarians?” My notes (including answers to this question) are below:

  • Nurses and Librarians?
    • gender
    • shortage
    • undervalued and underpaid
    • image problems
      • stereotypes
    • genetics?
      • how many of you are former nurses or studied nursing? (10%)
      • How many of your siblings/family members are nurses? (40% in the room!!)
  • why does our image matter?
    • budgeting issues
    • legislative issues
    • morale issues
    • recruiting issues
  • Personal Image
    • appearance
      • dress well: conveys confidence; sets them apart
      • hair–”serious hair” Working Girl
    • body language
      • you don’t have to feel confident to act confident
      • look in the eye, but not too much
        • don’t be the first to look away every time, just sometimes
      • stand up straight, head up
        • authoritative and assertive
    • speech…
      • most of us talk too much and have trouble getting to the core message
      • say things in different ways hopefully eventually it will come across
        • think of your most important message
        • think of how few words you can say it in
        • say it
        • then stay quiet
      • we have a bad habit: Oh, I’m sorry, I’ll come back…
        • unless you truly have something to be sorry for don’t say it
      • eliminate qualifiers: controlling the reaction of the listener before you say anything
        • you probably have heard this, but…
        • you probably won’t like this, but…
        • Problem: it takes to long to get to your point, lose your audience
      • You need to realize when you do this–self-awareness is the first step to eliminating the bad habit
        • Think before you speak
    • workspace/carspace
    • learn how to take a compliment
      • you did great: don’t mention it
      • thank you for your help: it’s my job
      • Accept it
        • you dishonor the person
        • yourself
        • your profession
      • Say: it was my pleasure; anytime; thank you for telling me that; let me know if I can do anything else for you.
      • appearing modest and humble is okay but you don’t have to be self-deprecating
    • Have a business card
      • have your academic credentials
      • carry the cards where ever you go, not just on your desk
      • have them made from where you work
        • not in the budget?
          • it costs next to nothing–people just never bother to ask
    • peoples’ impression is how they will treat you
      • we believe more of what we see than what we hear about or of people
  • Harnessing the power of the media
    • monitor images of librarians in the media–this is people’s perception of you
      • movies
      • sit-coms
    • stories about libraries or librarians
      • library budget cuts?
      • positive? negative? “Hipper Crowd of Shushers” positive but the stereotype is still there
        • let them know why it is detrimental
    • write letters to the media
    • Six Steps to Free Publicity, Marcia Yudin
      • Some people shy away from the media; read about it;
      • How can I say no, my whole profession is counting on me
        • clear communication is important; you are coached on general questions prior to recording
        • break down and eliminate industry jargon and acronyms
    • contact local media directly
      • I am the librarian at…
      • use National Library Week as a spring board
      • “You might be interested to know that…”
      • write letters to the editor if the information is accurate: offer additional resources and offer yourself as another resource
    • Being visible in the community
      • people will know you and your abilities
      • if you are unknown, it will not be hard to discourage bad local legislation
  • Promoting the profession
    • people don’t know about us; we don’t talk about ourselves enough
    • brochures and websites are not going to do the full job of educating peoples
    • don’t just say “I am a librarian, staff or MLS student”
      • add a sentence about what you did that particular day
    • get out to community fairs more
      • career fairs
      • scouting troops
      • school groups
      • Rachel Singer Gordon’s “How to become a librarian” article in Library Journal–this can help you describe what you do
    • Men/ ethnic minorities: people need to see people like them to go and pursue a career
  • Networking, getting visible;
    • attend a chamber of commerce meeting
    • a work meeting
    • women business owners in the community
    • promote our services on a regular basis
  • handshaking: important social custom; only form of acceptable touching connection
      • credibility
      • colleagues and clients; even children
      • sign of respect–levels the playing field
      • shake, eye contact, and smile
  • Marketing, staying visible
    • Always wear you’re name badge, title and credentials
    • photos of who works in the library with name, credentials and title for your users
      • you have to have the delineation: librarians are all different
    • sell your value on a daily basis
      • you can’t assume
        • people know who you are
        • know what you do
        • know what you have
    • consider writing a weekly/monthly column with your picture
      • tips
      • suggestions
      • different services
      • different materials
    • consider writing competitions
    • offer to speak at a local meeting on your paid work-time
      • propose these to the people you work for:
        • why do you want to go?
          • they vote
          • they donate money
          • they don’t appreciate/know our services
      • if you don’t ask you don’t get
      • even if it is no, it produces awareness
        • repackage it and try again
        • if we can’t do that, maybe we can do this
        • “When the customer says no, the selling begins.”
    • other ideas
      • Comment: in the public: at the gym or the grocery: what do you do: “I am your librarian”
      • Comment: offer comments and questions
        • always identify yourself by names and permissions
      • Comment: contacted local assembly person; they told her about meetings they are looking for speakers
        • if you don’t know your local assembly person is you can find out easily;
      • Comment: a lot of libraries have public meeting space: always make myself known and who I am
      • Comment: we have a speakers bureau and offer speakers in their interests
      • Comment: passed over for promotion; one of the reasons why I came I felt I might need to change my image…but I am becoming cynical and bitter; how do you turn that around?
        • A: changing your image is a good thing; there are a lot of reasons why people are hired; make an appointment to speak with your supervisor; let your goals be known and ask for advice; can you suggest other projects I can get involved in?
      • Comment: new hires get a mentor who give candid feedback and help them in promotion
      • Comment: enewsletter: would you like to sign up for our monthly newsletter with tips on research?
  • Getting involved in national/local associations
    • joining isn’t enough, get involved
    • dues are too much
      • ask for help from your employer
        • ask for help to go to conference
        • ask for it every year even if they say no every year
        • if you don’t ask you won’t get
        • nos still create awareness
        • why is it important to be a member?
          • why is it important to go to a conference
          • Comment: when you get back meet with supervisors and tell them why it was beneficial;
          • D: write a report, give the boss material
      • cost is relative to value
      • you can probably deduct this on taxes
    • they won’t listen to me; too much politics;
      • even if you put something out there and they don’t follow, you are still feeling empowered and your voice is heard
    • you will also need to sell this to other people
      • you join associations for what is in it for you
        • you are an informed member of the profession–pipeline of information
        • garner support
        • let off steam
      • join a committee
        • hones your leadership skills
        • your communications skills
        • your networking skills
    • run for office in your organization
      • this holds a lot of wait in your employment evaluations
  • Develop speaking and writing skills
    • promotion method
    • it is the good communicators who get ahead in this world
      • articulate
    • anyone can learn how to write and anyone can learn how to speak
      • more technique involve than most people realize
      • develop it and cultivate it
    • start small and start local
      • write about something you love
      • write about something you know
      • write about something innovative
      • write in an association newsletter
      • it is the doing that grows into ability
    • Getting a rejection letter
      • when I got my first one and vowed I would never write again
      • the editor had actually taken the time to make some suggestions
      • I never resubmitted that article, but I went to the public library and got a book on how to write for publication in journals
      • today I am doing a column for that magazine now
        • I almost let one rejection letter keep me from ever doing it again
      • WHEN you get a rejection letter, you celebrate that–it is a rite of passage
        • writing and submitting is the part of publication that is important
      • Speaking? I looked up books at the library on that as well